First Edition Arcanine (Base Set)
Arcanine did not receive a holofoil treatment in the original Base Set. Even so, its status among fans was nothing short of legendary. Labeled in the Pokédex as the “Legendary Pokémon,” this 1st Edition Arcanine was a brute force powerhouse. Many players preferred it over higher rarity cards due to its raw efficiency. The classic Ken Sugimori illustration features Arcanine mid-stride against a vibrant sunset orange background. This is one of the most recognizable pieces of art from the 1999 era.
For collectors, this is a “Semi-Rare” chase card. It appeared more frequently than the holos because it is an Uncommon. However, finding a 1st Edition Shadowless copy in perfect condition is a difficult feat. These cards now command a significant premium.
What Is Arcanine?
Card Name: Arcanine
Set: Base Set (1st Edition)
Rarity: Uncommon
Card Type: Fire
Artist: Ken Sugimori
Gameplay Highlights:
- Flamethrower: Arcanine dealt 50 damage for three energy. This required discarding one Fire energy. It was a consistent way to check Grass-type decks.
- Take Down: This was one of the hardest-hitting non-Holo attacks in the set. It dealt 80 damage for four energy. That was enough to one-shot most Stage 1 Pokémon. Arcanine took 30 recoil damage in the process.
- 100 HP Bulk: Arcanine had as much health as the “Big Three” starters. This made it an incredibly durable Stage 1 attacker.
- Retreat Cost: It had a massive three-energy retreat cost. Once Arcanine committed to a fight, it usually stayed until the end.
Historical Context and Collector Appeal
Arcanine was a staple in “Haymaker” variants. It was also popular in Mono-Fire decks that didn’t want to wait for the slow evolution of a Charizard. It provided an immediate, high-HP threat. It could pressure “Rain Dance” Blastoise decks before they could set up.
Collectors value this version because:
- The 1st Edition Stamp: This is the definitive mark of the very first print run.
- Shadowless Frame: This version features brighter yellow borders and a more saturated orange background. Later Unlimited versions are noticeably darker.
- High Design Quality: Many fans consider Arcanine’s design to be “Holo-worthy.” It remains one of the most popular Pokémon from Generation I.
- The Uncommon Challenge: Holos were usually protected in sleeves. Uncommons were often used as “workhorse” cards in casual play. High-grade 1st Edition copies are surprisingly scarce.
Current Market Data
The market for Arcanine has surged recently. Collectors are shifting focus toward high-grade Shadowless Uncommons to complete master sets.
Typical Price Ranges:
- Excellent to Near Mint (Ungraded): $75 to $140
- PSA 8 (Near Mint-Mint): $150 to $210
- PSA 9 (Mint): $275 to $450
- PSA 10 (Gem Mint): $1,900 to $2,300+
Condition Sensitivity
Finding a “Gem Mint” Arcanine is a test of patience. Specific print characteristics often affect the grade.
Strengths:
- Art Durability: The card does not have a holofoil surface. This means it doesn’t suffer from the same “starfield scratching” that plagues cards like Mewtwo.
- Iconic Contrast: The orange and red palette of the artwork is resistant to minor surface fading.
Common Issues:
- Centering: 1st Edition Base Set Uncommons are often “top-heavy.” Some are shifted to the left. This keeps many copies from reaching a PSA 10.
- Back Corner Whitening: Players handled this card frequently because it was a Stage 1 evolution. White nicks on the back corners are very common.
- Print Dots: Small magenta or cyan ink dots occasionally appear in the yellow border. This was common in early WotC print runs.
Why Arcanine Endures
- Legendary Identity: It is the only non-Legendary Pokémon to be categorized as the “Legendary Pokémon.”
- The Mini-Charizard: For many kids in 1999, Arcanine was the card you played if you couldn’t pull the Holo Charizard.
- Shadowless Scarcity: The 1st Edition Shadowless run is the most historically significant English printing of this card.
2 Comments