How to Start Collecting Magic: The Gathering
Magic has grown into a massive ecosystem over the past decade. New sets arrive faster, reprints land more consistently, and the number of printings for any given card can feel overwhelming. The challenge for new collectors in 2025 isn’t access. It’s direction. The best place to start is with a clear understanding of what matters and what doesn’t.
This guide focuses on fundamentals. The parts of collecting that stay consistent even as formats shift and product lines expand.
Start With a Format, Not a Set
Most collectors enter MTG through cards they already play, and in 2025 that typically means Commander. The format dominates both volume and visibility. It gives new collectors a clean starting point and a clear way to build around specific interests. Players who want more structure often end up in Modern, while Limited players tend to collect more casually through Draft and Sealed play.
The reason to pick a format early is simple. Each format has different staples, different priorities, and different value anchors. Collecting without that framework usually leads to scattered binders rather than a coherent base.
Focus on Staples, Not Chases
The backbone of any long-lasting collection is the set of cards that remain relevant year after year. These are the mana rocks, the efficient creatures, the reliable removal spells, and the format staples that never rotate out of usefulness. They’re not always exciting to buy, but they hold up through reprints and metagame changes.
Chase cards attract attention when they’re new, but they rarely define a collection. Staples do. The collectors who build steady value over time are the ones who understand that reliability is more important than flash.
Learn the Difference Between Printings
2025 MTG is defined by variants. Regular printings, foil, etched, retro, borderless, extended art. New collectors often underestimate how much printings matter. They affect availability, long-term desirability, and in some cases, liquidity.
The key is consistency. Pick a style early and build around it. Most well-organized collections follow a clear internal logic, and that clarity pays off later.
Understand How Reprints Work
Wizards reprints more aggressively now than at any point in the game’s history. Commander Masters, Secret Lairs, Universes Beyond releases, and various supplemental products mean that some staples get refreshed every few years.
This isn’t a bad thing. It creates entry points and stabilizes prices. But it also means collectors need to understand which categories absorb reprints smoothly and which do not. Broad utility staples tend to recover quickly. Narrow cards with limited homes do not.
Buy With Intent, Not Impulse
The fastest way to waste money in MTG is to chase cards that are trending for reasons that won’t matter in a month. Every set creates a wave of excitement, and the most expensive cards often settle once the dust clears.
The best collections are built slowly. They grow through deliberate additions, not impulse purchases. A small handful of cards that you know will remain relevant is worth more than a pile you bought because social media made them look important.
Build Your Storage Early
One of the most overlooked pieces of collection building is organization. Proper storage protects your cards and prevents long-term condition issues. Sleeves, binders, toploaders, and storage boxes are inexpensive compared to the value they preserve.
Collectors who build strong habits early usually avoid the most common pitfalls: scratched foils, binder dents, and disorganized piles that make valuation harder down the line.
Use Reliable Pricing and Reference Sources
Accurate pricing in MTG comes from triangulation, not a single website. MTGGoldfish, MTGStocks, Card Kingdom, and TCGPlayer all provide useful datapoints, but each reflects a different segment of the market.
Cross-referencing these sources helps collectors understand not just value, but also liquidity. Some cards sell immediately at market price. Others might require patience. Both matter when assessing long-term decisions.
A Stable Path Forward
Starting a Magic collection in 2025 doesn’t require chasing trends or trying to forecast the next breakout card. It requires an understanding of the fundamentals that have defined the game for decades: reliable staples, thoughtful organization, printings that make sense, and buying habits that aren’t driven by noise.
The strongest collections aren’t built quickly. They’re built with awareness, patience, and a clear sense of direction.
One Comment